When to Recover vs Replace: Cloth Decision Tree

Estimated Read Time: 6 mins | Updated: December 21, 2025

The playing surface is the soul of a pool table. Over time, chalk, friction, spills, and sunlight all leave their mark on cloth. But not every imperfection calls for a full replacement. Sometimes a simple re-covering of the slate and rails is enough. Other times, the cloth has reached its end of life and needs outright replacement. Here’s a decision tree to help you know which path to take.

Assess the Age of the Cloth
Look for Surface Damage
Check Play Quality
Evaluate Color & Aesthetic
Inspect the Slate & Cushions
Usage Context
Decision Tree (Summary)
Conclusion

1. Assess the Age of the Cloth

< 2 Years (light to moderate play): Likely recoverable unless visibly damaged.
2–5 Years: Inspect carefully — wear patterns may justify replacement.
5+ Years: Cloths typically lose nap, color, and consistency. Replacement is usually best.

2. Look for Surface Damage

Burn Marks: Cosmetic if isolated — recover if intact otherwise.
Tears or Cuts: Replacement required; patches ruin play consistency.
Heavy Pilling / Fuzz: If brushing can’t restore smoothness, replace.

3. Check Play Quality

Roll Speed Still Consistent?
Yes → Recover if only aesthetics are the issue.
No → Replace; worn cloth slows and affects accuracy.
Ball Tracking Straight?
Yes → Recover.
No → Replace; uneven nap or stretched fabric alters ball paths.

4. Evaluate Color & Aesthetic

Slight Fading: Recover may be enough.
Significant Fading / Stains / Sun Damage: Replacement restores appearance.

5. Inspect the Slate & Cushions

Slate & Cushions Fine: Cloth-only replacement is efficient.
Slate Gaps or Cushion Issues: Replace cloth while servicing underlying structure.

6. Usage Context

Private Home (Light Play): Cloth lasts 4–7 years; recovering may extend life.
Commercial / Club Use: High turnover — replacement every 12–18 months.
Tournament Play: Replace on a set schedule for consistency.